Re: Introduce Yourself
Posted: Tue Jun 23, 2026 12:27 pm
I think we're evaluating it from different positions. For me, the core of Idolmaster is that every producer has a different story with their idol. Not just participation, but irreducibly personal experience. You're valuing the overall production quality and storytelling, but it comes at the cost of what made the original irreplaceable.Thricegreat wrote: Tue Jun 23, 2026 11:11 amBut at the same time I think im@s is much more than just a game. Considering all those things at the same time, I think Gakumas is still doing a good job.
The Orthodox preference is interesting, do you mean that theologically or politically?He was too German. I'm inclined to rather Orthodox than Catholic unlike him. And while I agree with some of his criticism on liberal democracy, I prefer Plato's philosopher king over Schmitt's authoritarian leader.
I know that Nijigaku was a side project, and I specifically said that the individual focus was the right direction for the franchise. The original Love Live! was about group dynamics, Nijigaku was about individual character arcs. That's what I meant by "step backward into group dynamics."Although I'm not that enthusiastic these days, I have been following Nijigaku since 2018. So I think that you might be misinterpreting Nijigaku here.
Nijigaku was intended to be just a side project. It was never intended to become an anime at first and its start was just some characters in the games. A bit similar to Million, but it was far worse than that. The seiyuus were very surprised when they heard that it becomes an anime becaused of that.
So I think it has never been an orthodox Love Live! series and that's why I love it. I haven't been into the orthodox Love Live!.
On Hasunosora, if I consider the family tree of Love Live!, I think it is on the good side. Though I'm not that fan of the graduation system. Again Nijigasaki is not an orthodox Love Live! series.
And I don't think Nijigaku is orthodox either. That's exactly what I like about it.
Graduation system is stupid. If you're really into character development, why would you remove the characters you've grown attached to?

